This is Not Your Mommy’s Blog
Thursday, March 17th, 2011At a recent doctor’s appointment for Thomas his physician referred to me as “Mommy”. As in “Mommy, how many ear infections has Thomas had this year?” and “Don’t worry, your Mommy will be right here”. Apparently the doctor didn’t notice me shooting him my trademark look of scorn. The look that I often use successfully to make grown men recoil and stammer, “What’s wrong?” The doctor couldn’t have known that I despise being called “Mommy” – so much so that I don’t even allow my own children to call me by that name. But the doctor certainly did know that my name wasn’t “Mommy”. I had introduced myself to him as “Gina” as soon has he had walked into the room. The doctor used Thomas’ name easily, but somehow he never used my name once. Later that night I wondered aloud whether or not he would have called Jeff, “Daddy” had Jeff been the one to take Thomas to the appointment rather than me. Jeff thought I was overreacting. I was left with the feeling that I had underreacted. Although the replacement of my name with the more anonymous and diminutive “Mommy” bothered me deeply I had said nothing; not wanting to offend the man that would be performing surgery on my son.
Before they were born, I never gave any thought to what my kids would call me. I suppose that like most other American children of the ‘70s, ‘80s, and ‘90s I had begun by calling my mother “Mama”. I now simply call her “Mom”. Although I am almost certain there must have been an age that I called her “Mommy” I simply can’t remember every using that term with her. I was delighted when both of my children started off with the universal call of “Mama” as one of their first words. Somewhere around Thomas’ second birthday I noticed that some of the kids began to call their mothers “Mommy”. It was then that I realized how the very word “Mommy” sounded to me like nails being hammered into a coffin containing my identity as a strong, smart woman. I honestly couldn’t care less what other kids called their mothers: “Mama”, “Mommy”, “Mom”, or by their first names. But I care deeply about what my children and others call me. To my boys, I am “Mama”. Jeff jokes with me that sometimes “Mama” makes me sound like a large black woman. The thought makes me smile, as I think of a strong black woman keeping her boys in line. It contrasts in my head with my mental image of “Mommy”, a harried young woman in yoga pants running her kids to soccer practice in her SUV. There is no one right way to be a mother: it doesn’t matter what skin color you have, what you drive, what you wear, or what your kids call you. But somehow I identify with being a “Mama” rather than a “Mommy”.
Earlier this evening I was speaking with a colleague who had read this blog and suggested focusing it as a “mommy blog”, encouraging me that there was a market in such blogging. I clearly write about my family a great deal; stories of Thomas and Theo are woven throughout these pages. And I have actually thought on many an occasion that this blog needs a more tightly defined mission; be it mothering, sustainable cooking, or activism. I actually do have a food blog in the works, but to limit myself here to “mommy blogging” seems as much a straightjacket to me as the word “Mommy” itself.
Thomas tried out the name “Mommy” for me a few times and I gently, but firmly told him that I didn’t like that name and not to use it with me. When he asked why I told him, “I don’t completely understand why I don’t like it, but I know that I don’t. Somehow it makes me feel small, not like myself. I really like being called ‘Mama’ and I am so glad that I get to be your Mama.” I followed up with, “You don’t like to be called ‘Tommy’ right? It’s the same thing. Why don’t you like to be called ‘Tommy’”? I saw the light bulb of understanding go off over Thomas’ head and he replied thoughtfully, “I don’t like ‘Tommy’ because it is boring. Thomas is interesting. Let’s both call each other what we like.” It is moments like that, that make me proud to be his Mama.
“Mommy” might be easier for a busy physician to remember, it might be what all the other kids call their parents, and it might be a better way to reach an audience with my writing, but it is not who I am. Thomas has his surgery tomorrow and I have made a promise to myself that I will make sure that his doctor calls both of us by our proper names.