When you are the parent of a preschooler your weekend social scene revolves around birthday parties. Perhaps I am hopelessly lame, but I am starting to rather enjoy many of the parties: someone else provides entertainment for my children for a couple of hours, I get to eat food I did not have to make nor clean up after, and there’s always cake. We attended one of the more enjoyable parties this past Sunday morning. It was held outside in a shady, quiet park. The kids ran around with their friends and I actually found the time to chat with other parents. The hosts provided brunch, cake, crafts, and a pinata that they had thoughtfully filled with organic treats and goodies such as art supplies and accessories. After the post-pinata melee Thomas presented me with his bag of loot and as I perused it I sighed; not because it was filled with unhealthy hyperactive-inducing treats (it wasn’t) but because every single non-food item was clearly branded with either a “Spiderman” logo or a “Disney Princess”. There were rubber Spiderman bracelets and erasers, a heart shaped locket filled with lipstick and emblazoned with Rapunzel, and packages of crayons either boxed and wrapped in red and blue with Spiderman or boxed and wrapped in pink and purple with princesses. I wondered whether Thomas had noticed the overt gender stereotyping of the goodies – perhaps not. He had, after all, picked up an equal number of “boy” and “girl” items. He stuffed his haul into my bag and ignored it until we got home.
Once at home he quickly remembered and began to sort through his treasure. “Oooo fruit snacks!” “Oh a necklace…can you put it on me…wait (as he turned it over and saw the smiling face of a princess)…never mind. Here Mama, you can have it. It’s for you” “What are these…crayons? Oh I thought they were something to eat. Well, I’ll take these [the Spiderman crayons] and I’ll give these two packs to Theo [the princess crayons].” I couldn’t help but ask Thomas, “Why don’t you want those [the princess] crayons?” His answer was direct, “Because, you know, princesses are for girls and Theo doesn’t care yet.”
Thomas has never seen a “princess movie” nor has he seen “Spiderman”. But he goes to school three days a week, he plays with neighborhood kids, and he is quite observant. I wasn’t suprised that he had absorbed the pervasive “princesses are for girls” and “superheros are for boys” messages of our cultuure. And as much as I want to, at times, keep my kids in a bubble free from cultural influences; to do so is neither practical nor truly desireable. It would be an awfully lonely bubble for all of us and eventually they would inevitably break free regardless. Instead I am attempting to choose a middle path. I rather viigallantly control what the boys see in our own home: no cable TV, very limited viewing (an average of 30 minutes per day) of a pre-approved PBS show or a DVD, no toys that are weapons (they do make some out of Legos, etc. which I have made my peace with), no princess/diva/superhero/action figure toys, books, or movies, no clothes that have gender steroytyped sayings on them (“Daddy’s Little All Star”, “Shopper in Training”), and the boys go to a very gender cooperative/neutral school (they’ve even got two male preschool teachers there which is all kinds of awesome). And when they are exposed to something like gender packaged crayons I start asking questions. And so I inquired to Thomas, “Why do they have different packages of crayons for girls and boys? Are girl and boy crayons different? Do you know both girls and boys who like art?” As much as I was annoyed by the stupid crayons by that point, it was gratifying to see Thomas work through the answers to my questions, “I don’t know. Why are they different? That doesn’t make any sense. Art is for boys and for girls. I don’t think all girls like princesses.”
While we’ve talked about anatomy and gender with both boys time and time again (it turns out that when you are a little boy the concept that not everyone has a penis is quite mind-blowing) we’ve had mercifully little interaction with gender stereotypes. It seems that we’re just on the cusp of a big change in awareness of gender and culture in general. I think its going to be a difficult road to walk – at some point at least one, if not all, of my kids are going to test me. Thomas is going to denounce the pink shirt in his closet, Theo will tell me that there is something that girls “can’t” do, and/or baby girl will tell me that she wants to look “hot”. In the end the crayons were quickly forgotten for other pursuits. I hope that some of the questions will be remembered though. I can’t stop our consumer-driven culture from penetrating our lives but I will keep asking questions, teaching our children to challenge what they see and hear. Because, damn it, crayons should not have a gender attached to them. Let’s just let a crayon be a crayon.